Continuing the Conversation: The Wrong Question from the Author’s Guild
Sep. 11, 2026
Rethinking the E-Lending Debate
The Author's Guild just announced yet another study. Every one of these studies is built around the same question: is library lending taking money away from publishers and authors? It's the wrong question, and I think we should stop letting it set the terms of the conversation.
Here's the right question: who controls the terms libraries lend under, and are those terms fair to everyone at the table—authors, publishers, libraries, and readers?
Join Ann Ford, Hoopla's Vice President of Sales and Customer Support, as she Continues the Conversation on what the actual disagreement is about and why it makes a big difference.
Related Links:
Access and Fair Compensation Aren’t Opposites — No Matter What the Next Study Says
An Empirical Study of the Impact of Library E-Lending on the Book Economy — Secretariat Advisors, commissioned by the Association of American Publishers and Authors Guild
New Study Analyzes the Impact of Library E-Lending on Commercial Book Markets
Words & Money — Andrew Albanese: Publishing Industry “Study” Says Digital Library Lending Is Cannibalizing Retail Sales—Librarians Say It Reveals Something Else
Ron Charles: Libraries Are Not the Problem
ReadersFirst: Significant Flaw in New Library eBook Study
Publishers Weekly: In Final Order, Court Declares Maryland’s Library E-book Law Unconstitutional
Words & Money: Rhode Island Passes Its Library Ebook Bill
PEN America — Report: Public Libraries Face “Existential Threat”
Related Links:
Access and Fair Compensation Aren’t Opposites — No Matter What the Next Study Says
An Empirical Study of the Impact of Library E-Lending on the Book Economy — Secretariat Advisors, commissioned by the Association of American Publishers and Authors Guild
New Study Analyzes the Impact of Library E-Lending on Commercial Book Markets
Words & Money — Andrew Albanese: Publishing Industry “Study” Says Digital Library Lending Is Cannibalizing Retail Sales—Librarians Say It Reveals Something Else
Ron Charles: Libraries Are Not the Problem
ReadersFirst: Significant Flaw in New Library eBook Study
Publishers Weekly: In Final Order, Court Declares Maryland’s Library E-book Law Unconstitutional
Words & Money: Rhode Island Passes Its Library Ebook Bill
PEN America — Report: Public Libraries Face “Existential Threat”
