By Trenton Smiley, Director of Customer Messaging, Hoopla


You know the feeling. You leave a conference session buzzing with ideas, get back to your library, and the to-do list wins. That’s why I created the Library Marketing Makeover.

Inspired by home makeover shows, it’s a free Hoopla initiative. A team of volunteer library

marketing professionals and I review a library’s print materials, e-newsletters, social media, outreach, and website, then recommend fixes that fit its staff and budget. Partners like Koios and the John Henry Eldred Jr. Foundation help put those ideas into action.

Here’s how one library director described the experience:

Since we started, nearly 200 libraries have reached out for help. Across makeovers with the Library Cooperatives of Michigan, the Connecticut Library Consortium, and ARSL, the same five issues keep popping up. Here’s how to fix them.

  1. Your social feed is a bulletin board: If every post is an announcement, people scroll right past. Treat social media like a conversation instead. Ask questions (“What’s the last book you couldn’t put down?”), run quick polls, invite patrons to share their picks, and reply to comments so people know someone’s listening. Swap some flyers for real photos of patrons and staff. T he bonus: the more people engage, the more the platforms show your posts, including the promotional ones.
  2. Your flyers try to say everything: When everything gets equal billing, nothing stands out. Lead with the what, when and where, and send people online for the rest. A simple style guide and a few Canva templates keep everything consistent, even without a designer. Pro tip: give each audience its own color so patrons can spot what’s for them at a glance.
  3. Your e-newsletter is a wall of text: Not every detail needs to make it into the newsletter. Give each item a short teaser and a button that sends readers to your website for the rest. Aim for a good mix, too: a newsletter that’s all events starts to feel like a calendar. Pair upcoming programs with services patrons may not know about, like museum passes, research databases or your digital collection. Then check your click rates to see what readers want more of.
  4. Your promotion stays inside your walls: When library buildings closed during COVID, many libraries realized how much of their marketing was confined within their four walls. Flyers and desk handouts suddenly reached no one. The libraries that stayed connected were already meeting people online, in their inboxes and through partners.
    That lesson still applies: your next patron probably isn’t in your building, so go find them. Start with a Google Ad Grant, which gives eligible nonprofits up to $10,000 a month in free search ads to put the right service in front of the right person at the right time. Then stretch your reach even further with partnerships that share content, not just flyers.
  5. Your digital collection is treated like a separate library: Too often, digital gets its own separate corner of library marketing, promoted apart from everything else happening in your branches. But patrons don’t experience your library in pieces. When your programs, services, print collection and digital collection work together, every entry point leads somewhere new. A museum pass can lead to an eBook about the exhibit, and a cooking show can lead to a class in the branch. Whether patrons start in the branch or online, each connection opens the door to the rest of the library.

Think hybrid. The branch creates the moment, and digital keeps it going:

  • Book clubs and community reads: everyone can start the same title the same week, then gather in the branch to talk about it.
  • Storytime: send families home with a read-along or kids’ show that continues the theme.
  • Author visits and displays: add a QR code so patrons can borrow the book that night, even if the shelf copy is checked out.

Here’s one way it could come together: Ahead of the holidays, co-host a baking demo at the library with a local bakery or culinary school. Display cookbooks, lend baking pans (if you have them), and build a Hoopla private collection of cookbooks, cooking shows, and holiday music, featured in a custom carousel so patrons can’t miss it. Then keep the momentum going with a holiday cookie swap or a January cookbook club. Best of all, your partner helps spread the word.

The real makeover is a mindset

This project is personal for me. After years of marketing libraries, I love that the makeover lets Hoopla’s passion for libraries shine through. It isn’t about selling anything. It’s about helping libraries thrive.

Sharper flyers are nice, but the biggest shift is in how a library sees itself and its community.

My team and I wish that shift happened overnight, but rethinking old habits takes time, especially without a dedicated marketer. Whether it takes weeks or months, it’s all progress.

In the end, it’s not about getting noticed. It’s a shift from what the library offers to what your community needs, so your library shows up where people are when it matters most. That’s the real makeover.


Trenton Smiley

Trenton Smiley

Director of Customer Messaging,
Midwest Tape | Hoopla

LinkedIn